Are you or your subscribers not receiving your opt-in's incentive email? Here's what to check for.

This can be due to a deliverability issue, or something misconfigured in your account settings.

In this article, we'll walk you through everything you need to check, to diagnose why your incentive email isn't being delivered!

1. Did it go to the spam or promotions folder?

The first question to ask your subscriber, (or check yourself if testing your own opt-in), is whether the incentive email ended up in the spam folder.

If so, our deliverability lead has put together a comprehensive guide on troubleshooting this issue here: Why are my incentive emails going to spam?

2. Is your account approved?

The next thing to check for is whether your account is approved. If your account is not approved yet, you'll see this yellow bar across the top of your ConvertKit account:

No emails will be able to send until your account is approved. Click the banner to submit your account for approval and our team will be in touch as soon as possible.

NOTE: For more info on our approvals process, check out this article!

3. Is the incentive email enabled for the form?

If the email didn't go to spam, and your account is approved, the next thing to check is in the form settings itself.

To check if your form's incentive email is enabled, first click 'Settings' from the toolbar at the top of the form builder:

Then click 'Incentive' from the sidebar, and ensure 'Send incentive email' is checked:

NOTE: The incentive email won't send retroactively — it has to have been enabled before the time of the signup.

4. Are you sending from an @customdomain email address?

If the incentive email was enabled at the time of the signup, the next thing to check is your sending address.

Click the 'Edit Email Contents' button from the incentive email settings (see screenshot above), and in the modal that pops up, check the 'From email address'. This is its sending email:

This sending email should be an @customdomain email address like [email protected]. In other words, it should not be a freemail address ending in @gmail, @yahoo, @hotmail, etc. (This is true for all emails sent via ConvertKit — not just incentive emails!)

Using a freemail address as your sending address will harm your deliverability. We have more information on this here.

You can add a custom domain sending email in your account settings here.

NOTE: After adding an @customdomain email address as your sending address, we'd recommend setting it as your default and then deleting any freemail addresses from your settings so they don't get used by accident.

5. Check the subscriber's profile

The next step is to check the subscriber's profile. Search the subscriber's email address, or your own email address, if you were testing your own form. Find this from the search bar on the subscribers page, and then click from the list to view their profile.

Do you see the incentive email in their email history? If so, hover over the the icon next to it, to see if it may have bounced or failed to send:

6. Did you sign up for the same incentive email with the same address within the last 12 hours?

Incentive emails will only send once per subscriber per 12-hour period. So if you signed up to the same incentive email more than once (with the same email address) within a 12-hour period, you'll only receive it the first time, unless you delete yourself as a subscriber from your list in between tests.

☝️ PRO-TIP: If you're testing out your own opt-in multiple times with the same email address(es), you might want to consider using email aliases instead. Check out our guide on that here!

6. Give it time.

Usually incentive emails send very quickly; however, they can sometimes take a couple of minutes to come through. If you just signed up to your opt-in, the system might just need a bit of extra time to process the send!

Why are my incentive emails going to spam?

Did this answer your question?